Pages

Showing posts with label Ohio State U. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ohio State U. Show all posts

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Straws in the Wind - Part 509


From Inside Higher Ed: The Ohio State University College of Medicine discriminated in its admissions process, giving preference to Black and Hispanic applicants over white and Asian applicants, the Justice Department announced Wednesday. It's the 10th time this year the administration has found that a medical or law school discriminated, while 20 such investigations remain open... The DOJ letter... says OSU used a socioeconomic scale developed at UC Davis’s medical school, which the department considers a “race proxy.” The DOJ claims that UC Davis had discriminated in its medical school admissions, citing the same scale. According to the DOJ’s letter to Davis, that scale includes metrics like parental education level and coming from an “underserved area.”

The department also noted disparities in MCAT scores between admitted Black and Hispanic students and admitted Asian students: In 2025, the median MCAT score for admitted Black students was 514 (83rd percentile) and 515 (88th percentile) for admitted Hispanic applicants, while admitted Asian students had a median score of 517 (94th percentile)... Critics... argued that the findings often misinterpret the Supreme Court’s affirmative action ban, which allowed for the use of socioeconomic factors in admissions...

Full story at https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2026/10/22/osu-college-medicine-discriminated-doj-claims.

Tuesday, September 29, 2026

Straws in the Wind - Part 479

From Forbes: Add Vanderbilt University to the ever-lengthening list of premier institutions that are expanding their offers of free tuition to undergraduate students. The university announced last week that it was revising its Opportunity Vanderbilt financial aid program and will provide tuition-free scholarships to students from families with incomes up to $200,000 and typical financial assets. The previous threshold for free tuition was $150,000, which Vanderbilt established just two years ago, in 2024. The new eligibility criteria will take effect in fall 2027, and it will apply to both current undergraduate students as well as those who enter Vanderbilt next fall.

...Between 2024 and 2025, MIT, Carnegie Mellon University, the University of Texas, Brandeis University, the University of Utah, Smith College, Bryn Mawr College, the Stevens Institute of Technology, Wake Forest University, Emory University and The Ohio State University all rolled out their versions of free college tuition. The current year has seen a quickened pace of new offers. First, Yale University announced it was expanding its financial aid program and would offer free tuition to entering undergraduates from families with annual incomes below $200,000 and cover all the costs of attendance for those from families with incomes below $100,000. Two months later, the University of Notre Dame enhanced its undergraduate financial aid program so that students from families with annual income below $150,000 would have all their tuition costs covered starting in the 2026-27 academic year.

In May, the University of Chicago unveiled one of the most generous aid packages, guaranteeing free tuition starting in the fall of 2027 for undergraduate students from families with annual income less than $250,000. As part of its plan, Chicago promised it would cover tuition plus the costs of housing, meals and other fees for students from families with income less than $125,000. Rice University followed suit in August, announcing that it was expanding its major financial aid program and would, starting with students who enter in fall 2027, offer free tuition to those from families earning up to $200,000 annually...

Full story at https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltnietzel/2026/09/21/vanderbilt-to-pay-tuition-for-families-with-income--of-200000-or-less/.

Friday, March 27, 2026

UC-San Diego Med School Admissions Investigation

The US Dept. of Justice has announced an investigation into three med schools including at UC-San Diego, apparently related to the Supreme Court's anti-affirmative action decision. From the NY Times:

The Trump administration has opened investigations into admissions policies at three major medical schools, expanding the federal government’s pressure campaign beyond campus culture and taking aim at the heart of scientific authority in the United States. The Justice Department on Wednesday informed Stanford University, the Ohio State University, and the University of California, San Diego, about the investigations and demanded that the schools turn over extensive lists of data by April 24 or risk interruptions to essential federal funding...

The government is seeking information about medical school applicants from each of the past seven years, including test scores, home ZIP codes and any familial relationships to alumni or ties to university donors. The administration also demanded copies of any internal messages at the universities about diversity, equity and inclusion and any correspondence between school officials and pharmaceutical companies about admissions policies...

Officials at all three universities confirmed they had been notified about the inquiries. A Stanford spokeswoman declined to comment. U.C. San Diego said it was reviewing the notice from the Justice Department and that it was “committed to fair processes in all of our programs and activities, including admissions, consistent with federal and state anti-discrimination laws.” ...

Full story at https://www.nytimes.com/2026/03/26/us/politics/trump-medical-schools-civil-rights.html.

Saturday, September 6, 2025

Straws in the Wind - Part 93

From the Washington Post: Facing mounting pressure from the Trump administration, a lawyer for George Mason University President Gregory Washington told the board on Monday the leader had done nothing unlawful and would not apologize for his diversity, equity and inclusion policies, despite a call from the Education Department to do so. The federal agency’s Office of Civil Rights made a personal apology from Washington to the campus community part of a series of proposed steps to resolve a recent finding that the Virginia university had violated civil rights law by considering race in hiring and promotions. Washington has said the university’s policies complied with the law and were meant to expand opportunities.

Douglas Gansler, Washington’s lawyer, called the singling out of GMU from the Education Department bordering on the “absurd,” saying in his letter to the George Mason Board of Visitors that the department’s investigative process had been “cut short” after a “very incomplete fact-finding process,”

“The draft Resolution Agreement, in particular its demand that Dr. Washington apologize to the Mason community for promoting unlawful discriminatory hiring practices, would be falsely admitting to conduct that did not occur and would open GMU to further legal risk,” Gansler, a former Maryland attorney general, wrote in a letter obtained by The Washington Post...

Full story at https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2025/08/25/george-mason-president-refuses-apology-dei/.

From Inside Higher Ed: ...Faculty at Ohio State University can no longer make land acknowledgments—verbal or written statements that recognize the Indigenous people who originally lived on the university’s land—unless it is directly relevant to class subject matter. The new policy from the university’s Office of University Compliance and Integrity is one of many created in response to Ohio’s SB 1, a sweeping higher education law passed in March that seeks to eliminate DEI offices and scrub all mentions of diversity, equity and inclusion from university scholarships, job descriptions and more. The university has also limited student housing decorations in public spaces to “Ohio State spirit themes” and prohibited schools and departments from commenting on a wide array of topics, including the original inhabitants of the land on which the university is built.

Land acknowledgments are “considered statements on behalf of an issue or cause” and cannot be made by someone representing a unit, college or department, according to the new policy. Such statements cannot be used at virtual or in-person university-sponsored events, or written on any university channel, website, social media, signage, meeting agenda or event program. The acknowledgments are also banned from syllabi and class materials and cannot be spoken aloud in the classroom unless they are directly tied to the course, such as in a class about the history of American Indigenous peoples...

Full story at https://www.insidehighered.com/news/faculty-issues/academic-freedom/2025/09/03/ohio-state-bans-land-acknowledgments.

Monday, September 1, 2025

Straws in the Wind - Part 88

From the Austin American-Statesman: Faculty senates — a long-standing advisory body of elected members that helps university leadership on curriculum, policy and programs — will no longer exist at University of Texas institutions starting Sept. 1, after the UT System Board of Regents on Thursday approved compliance with Senate Bill 37. Chairman Kevin Eltife said the board will "take their time" deciding if faculty senates compliant with the law will be reinstated to university campuses, and may not be needed at all 14 campuses. "The Legislature spoke very clear through the legislation that governing boards are responsible for deciding if and when faculty senates will be established on campuses," he told regents... "That is a responsibility that this board takes very seriously."

...Lawmakers had cast faculty senates as powerful voices that should be curbed last legislative session. Sen. Brandon Creighton, R-Conroe, authored SB 37 to give regents more control following complaints from conservatives that the institution's faculty have become too liberal or "woke."

...Faculty advocates warned during the legislative session that shared governance is a hallmark of university operations, and weakening faculty senates jeopardizes that work...

Full story at https://www.statesman.com/news/education/article/university-texas-system-faculty-senate-abolish-20822502.php.

From Higher Ed Dive: ...With the passage of the new legislation, also known as SB 1, Ohio lawmakers made deep inroads into the academic operations of public colleges, asserting new state controls over decisions historically left to faculty and administrators. The law bans diversity, equity and inclusion training, requires post-tenure review, prohibits full-time faculty from striking and even requires certain questions in student evaluations of professors. SB 1 also created a policy that could wipe out dozens or even hundreds of academic programs if the experience of Ohio’s neighboring state is any gauge. 

In Indiana, a similar policy with programmatic graduation thresholds — inserted into the most recent state budget bill — has already put 75 degree programs on the chopping block. The state’s public colleges also moved to suspend another 101 programs and consolidate 232. As in Ohio, Indiana state colleges only had months to review their portfolios for cuts. That created uncertainty for many. “Even tenured faculty are wondering, am I going to have a job in two months?” one faculty governance leader in Indiana told local media, describing “chaos and confusion” on campus...

Full story at https://www.highereddive.com/news/ohio-university-program-cuts-comply-SB1/758788/.

Saturday, August 30, 2025

Straws in the Wind - Part 86

From the Columbus Dispatch: ...Former university President E. Gordon Gee will take on a one-year consulting role at Ohio State, which will include working with the new Salmon P. Chase Center by recruiting faculty and increasing the center's presence on campus and nationally, according to a copy of Gee's university contract obtained by The Dispatch. ...Gee will generally act as a resource for university leaders in advancing "their strategic priorities." He will report directly to Executive Vice President and Provost Ravi V. Bellamkonda and engage with leaders of the John Glenn College of Public Affairs, Moritz College of Law and Chase Center. 

Through these three collaborations, Gee's contract says he will provide support, advice and open dialogue with programs and institutions nationwide that may be interested in working with the university. The contract goes on to mention Gee will further advance the Chase Center by working with its director, Lee Strang.

...The Chase Center, an "intellectual diversity" center created through the passage of Ohio Senate Bill 117, was established to promote civil discourse and prevent alleged leftist ideology from "replacing the lessons of history" on college campuses, according to a news release* from Sen. Jerry Cirino, a Republican from Kirtland, one of the bill's sponsors...

===

*https://www.ohiosenate.gov/members/jerry-c-cirino/news/special-commentary-by-senator-cirino-on-landmark-higher-education-reform.

===

Full story at https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/local/2025/08/19/former-ohio-state-osu-president-e-gordon-gee-returns-campus-consulting/85723386007/.

==========

From the Brown Daily Herald: About 15 incoming international students are “unable to reach” Brown’s campus for the start of the fall semester, President Christina Paxson P’19 P’MD’20 wrote... Most of these affected students were graduate students, Paxson wrote, adding that “many others” have decided to defer their studies. About a third of graduate students and 14 percent of undergraduate students at Brown come from outside of the United States. The challenges come amid a variety of new obstacles that the Trump administration has put in place for international students seeking to study in the U.S. These students were impacted by delays in visa appointments and approvals, according to Amanda McGregor, a spokesperson for the University...

Full story at https://www.browndailyherald.com/article/2025/08/about-15-incoming-international-students-unable-to-reach-campus-this-fall-paxson-says.

Sunday, November 12, 2023

The Way We Live Now - Continued

Columbia, MIT Discipline Student Groups for Anti-Israel Protests

  • Schools face complaints they’re not protecting Jewish students
  • Free speech concerns eclipsed by student safety, school rules

By Janet Lorin

November 10, 2023, Bloomberg

A handful of US colleges, including Columbia University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, have started to take action against pro-Palestinian protests deemed to be against school rules or hostile to Jewish students.

Columbia University on Friday temporarily suspended two student groups supporting the Palestinian cause that it said repeatedly violated university policy after an unauthorized event proceeded “despite warnings and included threatening rhetoric and intimidation,” the Ivy League school said in a statement.

MIT stopped short of suspending students because of potential visa issues but barred them from non-campus activities while the school investigates a protest conducted in defiance of school rules that was “disruptive, loud and sustained through the morning hours,” the university said in a statement.

US universities have been hesitant to draw boundaries around free speech, but they now appear comfortable finding rule breaches by demonstrators, whose rallies have sometimes led to intimidation, physical altercations and accusations of antisemitism. Parents and alumni have threatened to stop donating, saying the schools weren’t doing enough to keep Jewish students safe.

At Ohio State University, two incidents directly targeted the Jewish community in 24 hours. Two students were assaulted and the campus Hillel was vandalized, the school’s president said Friday. At Cornell, online threats against Jews resulted in a student’s arrest. At Columbia, Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace, an anti-Zionist group, were suspended through the end of the fall term and won’t be eligible to hold events on campus or receive university funding, said Gerald Rosberg, senior executive vice president.

On Thursday, hundreds of students participated in a walkout at the New York City school sponsored by the two groups. Protesters wanted the university to “take action by calling Israel’s attacks a genocide and canceling the University’s business interests and partnerships in Israel,” according to the Columbia Spectator, the student newspaper. “Lifting the suspension will be contingent on the two groups demonstrating a commitment to compliance with University policies and engaging in consultations at a group leadership level with University officials,” Rosberg said in the statement.

Brandeis University in Massachusetts this week stopped recognizing its chapters of Students for Justice in Palestine because it openly supports Hamas, which is labeled a terrorist group by the US, according to President Ron Liebowitz.

“All students, faculty, and staff are welcome here, and encouraged to participate in the free exchange of ideas,” Liebowitz said. “To promote such free exchange, we must not and do not condone hate, the incitement of violence, or threats against or harassment of anyone, be they Jewish, Muslim, Christian, Buddhist, Hindu, Israeli, Palestinian, or any other religion or ethnicity.”

Source: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-11-10/columbia-mit-discipline-student-groups-for-anti-israel-protests.

Tuesday, August 22, 2023

The Data Fraud Case - And Still More

An analysis in the Chronicle of Higher Education suggests that lawsuits are a blunt instrument for dealing with allegations of data manipulation. The problem in the recent high-profile Harvard case is that the response to the allegation seems to be that maybe it happened, but it wasn't me who did it. So, like self-driving cars, we seem to have self-manipulating data.

When Scholars Sue Their Accusers
Francesca Gino is the latest. Such litigation rarely succeeds.

By  Adam Marcus and  Ivan Oransky
8-18-23

Francesca Gino has made headlines twice since June: once when serious allegations of misconduct involving her work became public, and again when she filed a $25-million lawsuit against her accusers, including Harvard University, where she is a professor at the business school. The suit itself met with a barrage of criticism from those who worried that, as one scientist put it, it would have a “chilling effect on fraud detection.” A smaller number of people supported the move, saying that Harvard and her accusers had abandoned due process and that they believed in Gino’s integrity.

How the case will play out, of course, remains to be seen. But Gino is hardly the first researcher to sue her critics and her employer when faced with misconduct findings. As the founders of Retraction Watch, a website devoted to covering problems in the scientific literature, we’ve reported many of these kinds of cases since we launched our blog in 2010. Plaintiffs tend to claim defamation, but sometimes sue over wrongful termination or employment discrimination, and these kinds of cases typically end up in federal courts. A look at how some other suits fared might yield recommendations for how to limit the pain they can cause.

The first thing to know about defamation and employment suits is that most plaintiffs, but not all, lose. Mario Saad, a diabetes researcher at Brazil’s Unicamp, found that out when he sued the American Diabetes Association in the very same federal district court in Massachusetts where Gino filed her case.

Saad was trying to prevent Diabetes, the flagship research journal of the American Diabetes Association, from publishing expressions of concern about four of his papers following allegations of image manipulation. He lost that effort in 2015, and has now had 18 papers retracted.

That same year, The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition prevailed in a case brought by a researcher who tried to stop its editors from retracting one of her papers.

In 2016, Fazlul Sarkar lost a court bid to unmask the name of an anonymous commenter on PubPeer, a platform for such comments, whose criticism he blamed for costing him a job offer. Sarkar has now had 41 papers retracted.

In 2021, Rhawn Joseph, the “prince of panspermia,” had a $50 billion — no, that’s not a typo — case against Springer Nature over a retraction tossed by a federal judge. Joseph, as the judge in the case noted, “considers himself ‘one of the leading figures in the search for extraterrestrial life,’” and panspermia proponents posit that life arose elsewhere in space and then made its way to Earth. He has, he says, proved conclusively that there is life on Mars, but that NASA and the scientific community have responded with “slander, defamation and death threats.”

And this year, a judge upheld a decision against Pacira Biosciences, which had sued the American Society of Anesthesiologists over papers published in its flagship journal that were critical of Exparel, an analgesic sold by Pacira used to prevent pain after surgery.

Not all plaintiffs do so poorly. Elsevier settled a case in 2011 brought by an advocate for intelligent design who objected to the retraction of his paper. The author, Granville Sewell, had argued that “the Second Law of Thermodynamics makes it impossible for evolution to improve living organisms,” according to Joe Felsenstein. But as Felsenstein, a biologist, notes, “The obvious reply is that the biosphere is not an isolated, closed system, that to come near having one, we must also include the sun which undergoes a huge increase of entropy as it radiates energy, that more than compensates for the much smaller decrease of entropy involved in the evolution of life.”

Still, Elsevier agreed to publish a retraction notice that said the move was “not because of any errors or technical problems … but because the Editor in Chief subsequently concluded that the content was more philosophical than mathematical” and therefore not a good fit for the journal. The journal also offered its “sincere and heartfelt apologies” to Sewell.

Elsevier lost another case brought by a researcher who said the company had used “untruthful and unverified” language in a retraction notice. That notice, published in 2011, said the authors had “misappropriated data, plagiarized and concealed the authorship of work.” But after the researcher sued, the journal toned down the notice to say simply that “some of the findings have previously been published … without proper cross-referencing.”

And two researchers at the University of Pittsburgh earned a settlement with a journal that left their paper retracted but changed the wording of the notice to make them appear less culpable.
Then there are those cases where critics use the courts to press their claims. The fitness giant CrossFit won nearly $4 million in legal sanctions after charging that The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research had defamed the company in a since-retracted paper. That paper had claimed nine of 54 participants dropped out of a study of CrossFit workouts because of “overuse or injury.” But it turned out that just two had dropped out — and neither because of such issues. The paper was eventually retracted for lack of institutional-review-board approval.

And Joseph Thomas, a whistle-blower at Duke University, earned $34 million in a case that cost the university a $112.5-million settlement — not to mention untold legal fees. Thomas — who was a technician in a lab that studied the effects of pollution on the lungs — alleged that Duke had knowingly included faked data in grant applications and reports for grants totaling $200 million.

The issues might have gone unnoticed were it not for the fact that the technician blamed for them, Erin Potts-Kant, had been caught embezzling more than $25,000 from the lab. That crime prompted an examination of data she generated, which had made it into some 50 studies. The scrutiny revealed serious issues, and 18 papers co-authored by Potts-Kant have now been retracted, and she has been banned for life from receiving federal funding — but Duke scientists and officials tried to cover it up, according to Thomas. In the end, Duke paid a hefty price, the largest such settlement by a university under the False Claims Act.

Such cases can be extremely expensive — not only for the defense, whether the costs are borne by institutions or insurance companies, but also for the plaintiffs. Ask Carlo Croce and Mark Jacobson.

Croce, a cancer researcher at Ohio State University, has at various points sued The New York Times, a Purdue University biologist named David Sanders, and Ohio State. He has lost all of those cases, including on appeal. The suits against the Times and Sanders claimed that a front-page story in 2017 that quoted Sanders had defamed Croce. His suit against Ohio State alleged that he had been improperly removed as department chair.

Croce racked up some $2 million in legal bills — and was sued for nonpayment. A judge has now ordered Croce’s collection of old masters paintings to be seized and sold for the benefit of his lawyers, and has also garnished Croce’s bank accounts. Another judgment means that his lawyers may now foreclose on his house to recoup their costs. Ohio State has been garnishing his wages since March by about $15,600 each month, or about a quarter of his paycheck. He continues to earn more than $800,000 per year from the university, even after a professorship and the chair were taken away from him.

When two researchers published a critique of the work of Mark Jacobson, an energy researcher at Stanford University, in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Jacobson sued them along with the journal’s publisher for $10 million. He dropped the case just months after filing it.

But thanks to a so-called anti-SLAPP statute, “designed to provide for early dismissal of meritless lawsuits filed against people for the exercise of First Amendment rights,” a judge has ordered Jacobson to pay $500,000 in legal fees to the defendants. Jacobson wants Stanford to pay those costs, and California’s labor commissioner said the university had to pay at least some of them because protecting his reputation was part of Jacobson’s job. The fate of those fees, and who will pay them, is up in the air, with Jacobson once again appealing the judgment against him.

Even when defendants prevail, they do not always emerge unscathed. David Sanders, the Purdue researcher Croce sued, won that case, and his employer covered his legal fees. He remains a tenured professor. But his college and department “did not recognize my scientific-integrity efforts as valuable,” he told Retraction Watch two years ago when reflecting on the case.

“Indeed, it was conveyed to me that some of my investigatory endeavors, although they were not directed towards articles with authors from my university, were unwelcome,” Sanders told us. “There was a concomitant withdrawal of resources from my laboratory and me.”

In general, such lawsuits are a terrible way to respond to criticism — even, perhaps, illegitimate criticism. For one, judges and juries are, by design, not experts in any of the scientific subject matter. Here’s what Judge Timothy S. Hillman of the U.S. District for the District of Massachusetts noted in a ruling on Saad’s suit against the American Diabetes Association: “The dispute between Dr. Saad and the ADA over the reliability of the data in his articles is not fit for resolution in the form of a defamation lawsuit. Instead, this is a case where ‘the trial of ideas plays out in the pages of peer-reviewed journals, and the scientific public sits as the jury.’”

The fact that such cases are brought to court cannot but have a chilling effect. Would-be-critics self-censor. Publishers fail to correct the record. And universities protect fraudsters. Just ask Paul Brookes, who anonymously created a now-defunct site called Science-Fraud.org in 2012. His work drew praise, but it also drew the ire of his targets, who called for a lawsuit. When his university told him it would not cover his legal expenses, he shut down his site. In the years since, the substance of his efforts has proved right time and time again.

Regardless of how such cases and legal threats tend to play out, it seems highly unlikely that they will go away. If anything, in an age where scientific sleuthing is having a welcome moment, they appear likely to multiply. We’ve reported on two new cases since July.

With that in mind, we have two suggestions. The first is that sleuths use PubPeer to make their critiques anonymously. The site, a nonprofit founded in 2012, allows for comments on any papers that contain a digital object identifier (DOI) — a unique string of characters designed to track publishing events related to an article — or PubMed ID. Commenters may use their real names, or a pseudonym. The platform has proved resilient in the face of legal threats and has led to countless corrections, retractions, and university investigations. (Full disclosure, one of us is a volunteer member of PubPeer’s board of directors.)

The second is that critics might consider publishing their work under the umbrella of media organizations like Retraction Watch that have experience in this area — and defamation insurance. Underwriters tend to set a high bar for such policies, and they are out of reach of most individuals.

Working with media organizations will not prevent all lawsuits. But doing so will make them less likely because experienced journalists who know the definition of libel will serve as trainers and backstops — and will often consult with legal counsel before publishing. Those of us who have been doing this work a long time have learned from school, training, and the lawyers we’ve worked with certain rules of attribution and vocabulary. For example, we would have advised Brookes to avoid using the word “fraud” in his URL.

And partnerships could make the financial burden far less crushing if a suit does occur, since the media outlets (reputable ones, anyway) will have the shield of libel insurance. Raising a deductible from supporters is much easier than raising $1 million to defend against a suit. (A group of scientists have launched a $250,000 GoFundMe campaign to pay the legal costs of Gino’s accusers, for example.)

These kinds of collaborations will lead to more impact, and hopefully to even more skilled critics. Publishers have made it clear they have little interest in this work, and are happy to outsource it, so unless critics keep up their efforts, the scientific literature will remain sullied.

See you in court — or perhaps not.

Source: https://www.chronicle.com/article/when-scholars-sue-their-accusers.

Monday, December 26, 2022

It pays to have a med school


The federal government accounts for over half of the R&D expenditures in higher ed. And health research accounts for over half of that source. Below is a ranking of higher ed institutions by R&D expenditures:

30 institutions reporting the largest FY 2021 R&D expenditures in all fields: FYs 2019–21 


Click on table to enlarge and clarify.

a Johns Hopkins University includes the Applied Physics Laboratory, with $1,950 million in total R&D expenditures in FY 2021.

b University of Maryland includes expenditures from University of Maryland, Baltimore and University of Maryland, College Park campuses. In FY 2019, the two campuses began reporting as one research unit to reflect their new strategic partnership. 

Source: https://ncses.nsf.gov/pubs/nsf23303.

Monday, August 8, 2022

NIL ain't nothing anymore - Part 2

Back in April, we noted the growing significance of NIL (money for Name, Image, Likeness) for college athletes, now available thanks to the Supreme Court.* Presumably, the idea was that those athletes who had developed high-profile reputations could cash in on brand endorsements, etc. 

A recent LA Times article, however, suggests that NIL has opened the door to use of promises of NIL for recruitment. That is, athletes who have yet to develop high-profile reputations, but look promising as recruits, are being promised NIL deals through workarounds such as alumni donations. UCLA claims not to be doing this, and says it just facilitates already-recruited athletes in developing their own NIL deals. But if some universities are using NIL for workaround recruitment deals, it puts pressure on others to compete.

From the LA Times: College football coaches appear to have found a workaround for rules barring them from soliciting name, image and likeness deals for their players. Just create a sense of panic. Two months ago, Ohio State coach Ryan Day told local business leaders that his team would need $13 million in NIL money to keep its roster intact. A month later, Rutgers coach Greg Schiano reportedly informed a group of boosters that his team required an infusion of cash to keep players from being poached by more NIL-savvy teams. In each case, the message was clear to any fan, booster or business listening: Show us the money.

UCLA coach Chip Kelly said Saturday that he could only support his team’s NIL endeavors from afar. “I think people have kind of convoluted the whole rule,” Kelly said. “Name, image and likeness is the student-athletes can make money off of their name, image and likeness, but coaches can’t be involved in brokering deals for student-athletes. This is not pay for play, this is not recruiting inducements.” ...

Full story at https://www.latimes.com/sports/ucla/story/2022-08-06/ucla-football-chip-kelly-nil-success-ncaa-rules.

===

*https://uclafacultyassociation.blogspot.com/2022/04/nil-aint-nothing-anymore.html.

Sunday, December 19, 2021

Stuff Happens (and is happening) - Part 2

From the LA Daily News: The basketball teams at UCLA won’t be returning to the court any time soon. The men’s basketball team had its Wednesday nonconference game against Cal Poly canceled Saturday due to the COVID-19 protocols within the Bruins’ program. It’s the third consecutive game canceled for the fourth-ranked Bruins after games with Alabama State on Wednesday at Pauley Pavilion and North Carolina on Saturday in Las Vegas were recently called off. The game with Cal Poly will not be rescheduled. “UCLA’s team-related activities have been paused, and the status of future games is to be determined,” a UCLA release said.

The women’s basketball team, which had to cancel Thursday’s game against Texas Southern due to COVID-19 protocols within the Bruins’ program, announced that home games against Ohio State on Sunday and Cal State Bakersfield on Tuesday won’t be played either. The next game on the men’s team’s schedule naturally becomes a question, which is a Pac-12 game against No. 8 Arizona on Dec. 30 at Pauley Pavilion. The women’s team has a Pac-12 game with USC scheduled for Dec. 28 at Pauley Pavilion.

COVID-19 related issues have shut down college basketball programs all over the country. Ohio State, which was supposed to take on Kentucky in the CBS Sports Classic, canceled because of positive COVID-19 results within the 15th-ranked Buckeyes’ program. Seton Hall canceled its games against Iona and St. John’s. It’s part of a growing wave of COVID-19-related sports cancellations and postponements as the pandemic surges again this winter...

Full story at https://www.dailynews.com/2021/12/18/ucla-mens-and-womens-basketball-teams-stalled-by-covid-19-protocols/.

Thursday, August 27, 2020

Does it pass the sniff test?

From The Lantern: The (Ohio State) university Board of Trustees is set to award former University President Michael V. Drake a performance bonus of $133,792. The Talent, Compensation and Governance Committee approved the bonus to be voted on by the full Board at its meeting Thursday. Drake became president of the University of California system in early August after serving as Ohio State’s 15th president for six years. 

The bonus is 15 percent of his annual base salary of $891,946 at Ohio State, according to the meeting agenda. He will receive an annual base salary of $890,000 from the University of California and is taking a voluntary, temporary pay reduction of 10 percent through June 30, 2021 due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to July, 7 Board of Regents agenda...


Monday, July 20, 2020

Drake's Cautious Answer on SAT/ACT

Incoming UC prez Michael Drake was cautious about answering a question on the use of the SAT or ACT for admissions on "Face the Nation" yesterday:

...MARGARET BRENNAN: Now that you're at UC, they have taken some high profile steps to attempt to increase diversity within the school system. One of the more controversial ones was this decision to do away with the requirement of SAT or ACT tests in the future, despite some arguments within the university that that doing so would result in lower grade averages or lower graduation rates. And I wonder how you think about addressing these concerns that- that eliminating the standard somehow lowers them?

DR. DRAKE: Well, we are in no way attempting to lower standards at all. We have a variety of things that we consider in admissions. I was admissions- in charge of admissions for the UCSF Medical School for many years and in the past. And we used a variety of things to determine the qualifications for students who are going to be admitted to our university. We're very proud that we have so many students interested in attending and we have to judge between them. And what we found is that standardized tests provide marginal information. They- they can help, but they don't tell the whole picture. And particularly in this time of COVID, when the- the opportunity to study and prepare for a test is quite uneven between those students who might be applying for us, we wanted to remove any potential barriers for students who might not have access to all the support that they need during this time to prepare for taking the test and therefore artificially score lower than they might. So the- the plan is to retreat from those standardized tests now and to think about other ways that we might gather that information as we look forward in the future. It's an ongoing discussion for us.

Full interview at https://www.cbsnews.com/news/transcript-dr-michael-drake-on-face-the-nation-july-19-2020/.

Note that Ohio State does require the SAT or ACT, although it has made the tests optional for this year due to the coronavirus sitution. See below from the Ohio State website:


Source: http://undergrad.osu.edu/covid-19-response/students-applying-for-autumn-2021#test-optional-faqs

Tuesday, July 7, 2020

Dr. Michael Drake is the New UC President

From the LA Times: Michael V. Drake, a national champion for access and equity who previously headed Ohio State University and UC Irvine, (is) named the new president of the University of California and first Black leader in the system’s 152-year history...

Under his tenure, (OSU) boosted the number of students who are low-income, underrepresented minorities and the first in their families to attend college. Black students, however, remain underrepresented at Ohio State, accounting for 6.8% of enrolled students in a state where Black residents make up 13% of the population. That’s a larger gap than at UC campuses, where Black students account for about 4% of enrollment compared with the state’s proportion of Black residents at 6%.

At Ohio State, Drake also worked to lower the cost of attendance and increase financial aid — issues that loom large for UC students. He introduced a financial model that raises costs for tuition, mandatory fees, housing and dining once for incoming freshmen, then locks them in for four years. Under his tenure, Ohio State boosted financial aid to low- and moderate-income Ohioans by more than $200 million since 2015, twice his initial target, and increased grants and scholarships.

He is also credited with helping Ohio State hit record highs in applications, graduation rates and sponsored research awards. Last year, he announced a $4.5-billion fundraising campaign, the largest goal in the school’s history.

While some faculty at both Ohio State and UC Irvine said he was not the most visible or hands-on academic leader, he was popular with students. Alexis Gomes, an incoming fifth-year Ohio State student in neuroscience, said students appreciated his initiatives to cut fees, lower textbook costs and provide all students with an iPad, Apple pencil and a notetaking app...

Full story at https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-07-07/michael-v-drake-is-expected-to-be-named-uc-president-first-black-leader-in-systems-152-year-history

Note: We will archive the audio of the special Regents meeting of today where the announcement was made when it is available.

Friday, September 30, 2016

At the top

Inside Higher Ed picks up on the poor-returns-to-endowments thing, with UC tied with Ohio State U for the top (worst) results.* Of course, all we have to do is get rid of the minus (-) sign and we could be at the bottom (best) along with Yale.
---
*https://www.insidehighered.com/news/2016/09/30/low-endowment-returns-dont-stop-regulation-push
---
Anyway, with all the concern about rankings, we're on top:

Friday, August 19, 2016

BART?

From Inside Higher Ed:

For months, officials at the University of Iowa have been saying that they would launch a Bias Assessment and Response Team this fall. Such teams exist at many other colleges and universities and typically use the acronym BART.
Many advocates for minority students have pushed for the creation of BARTs, and the Black Student Union at Iowa reviewed and approved the idea of starting one.
But on Thursday, the university's chief diversity officer, Georgina Dodge, announced a change of course. The university will not be unveiling a BART at the start of the academic year, she said. Rather, it will respond to criticism of the BARTs elsewhere by creating a model that would not in any way intrude on faculty members' academic freedom.
"We have seen that the ways BARTs are functioning at some other institutions are not effective, and we want to build a better BART," she said.
BARTs differ somewhat from campus to campus, but the one at Ohio State University, which Dodge has said in the past was a model for efforts at Iowa, describes itself this way: "BART receives, monitors, refers and, as necessary, coordinates university responses to hate- and bias-related incidents that impact all or a significant portion of the university community. Incidents may involve bias or hate as a result of age, ancestry, color, disability, gender identity or expression, genetic information, HIV/AIDS status, military status, national origin, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation, or veteran status."
Asked where she saw problems with a BART, Dodge cited the example of the University of Northern Colorado.
The BART at Northern Colorado became controversial this year after faculty members reported being told how they might change their classroom instruction to avoid offending some students. Many faculty members and others said the BART was effectively policing academic speech...

Tuesday, February 23, 2016

Outsource

Chelsea Workman went to Ohio State University because it was her cheapest option. But she still had to take out student loans and work to make ends meet. By the middle of her sophomore year, she'd had enough. She dropped out and moved to Germany to finish her degree where college is free. Hunter Newsome, from California, decided to go to college in Estonia rather than the University of California, Davis -- at the very last minute. He's saving more than $10,000 a year on tuition, and he'll earn a bachelor's degree in three years rather than four. There are at least 44 schools across Europe where Americans can earn their bachelor's degree for free, according to Jennifer Viemont, the founder of an advising service called Beyond The States. All public colleges in Germany, Iceland, Norway and Finland are free for residents and international students. And some private schools in the European Union don't charge for tuition either. Many are going out of their way to attract foreigners by offering programs taught entirely in English...

Full story at http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/23/pf/college/free-college-europe/index.html

Cheap:

Friday, January 31, 2014

UC-Irvine Chancellor Going to Ohio State U

News reports say that Chancellor Michael Drake of UC-Irvine is leaving to head Ohio State U.

Maybe he hasn't been reading weather forecasts:
Or maybe it was just irresistible: