Pages

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

More Regents Questions from Claude

Getting used to Claude as a pretend Regent? Your truly asked Claude to review items F6 and F7 from the agenda today, summarize, and ask questions. Both are UCLA items. Below is the response:

Regent's Risk Review: UCLA Capital Items F6 and F7

Finance and Capital Strategies Committee, Meeting of November 18, 2026
Prepared from the Office of the President action items. This is a cautious review written from a regent's point of view.

Bottom line

Each item has a sound purpose. The risks are different:

  • F6 (Research Park East) asks us to approve $137 million of new UCLA debt while the campus fails two of the three tests in the University's Debt Policy. The CFO has granted an exception. Most of the construction would also be run by an outside nonprofit under an agreement that is still being negotiated.
  • F7 (West Valley Hospital) asks for $120 million just for preliminary plans on a project whose total cost is not disclosed. That project will very likely cost more than $1 billion. It also follows an acquisition whose original retrofit plan has now been abandoned, and it will miss the state's 2030 seismic deadline.

I would not oppose either item outright. I would want the questions below answered on the record before voting, and I would consider asking for conditions on F6.


Item F6: UCLA Research Park East Core and Shell Improvements (Budget and External Financing)

What is being proposed

  • Retrofit about 530,000 gsf of the 736,000-gsf east building of UCLA Research Park for multi-tenant scientific use, mainly biomedical and quantum physics labs. Initial occupants: the California Institute for Immunology and Immunotherapy (CIII), the Geffen School of Medicine, and the UCLA Quantum Innovation Hub.
  • The work covers new mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems, converting rooftop parking to a central plant, floodproofing and floodplain mitigation, and new entries and lobbies. Lab tenant improvements are not included. They will come back as separate projects, starting with preliminary plans in March 2027.
  • Total budget: $327.9 million. In September 2026 the Regents approved $54 million for preliminary plans, working drawings and Advanced Work Phase construction.
  • Funding sources:
    • Campus funds: $44.9M (13.7%)
    • External financing repaid from campus general revenues: $92.2M (28.1%)
    • External financing repaid from gifts: $44.8M (13.7%)
    • CIII funds: $145.9M (44.5%)
    UCLA's share is therefore about $182 million.
  • Debt service, at a 4.25% planning rate over 30 years (2029–2058): about $5.49M a year on the $92.2M and $2.67M a year on the gift-supported $44.8M. That totals about $8.2M a year.
  • Delivery: Under the 2024 Master Lease and Affiliation agreement, CIII would lead construction using a Construction Manager at Risk (CMAR), and the same CMAR would build CIII's tenant improvements. The Work Agreement with CIII is still being negotiated.
  • Schedule: Advanced Work runs Oct 2026 – Jan 2027. Full construction runs Dec 2026 – May 2029.

Key risk flags

  1. The campus fails the Debt Policy. The minimum modified cash flow margin is -0.4% against a required ≥0.0%. Debt service coverage is 0.5x against a required ≥1.1x, a threshold the attachment marks "Must Meet." Only days cash on hand passes (102 days against ≥90), and only narrowly. A coverage ratio of 0.5x means projected cash flow covers about half of debt service. The CFO granted an exception. The Regents should understand that we are being asked to approve debt the University's own policy would normally reject.
  2. The gift-backed debt is really campus debt. The $44.8M is repaid "from gift funding," but the pledged security is the same as for the other loan: general revenues of the Los Angeles campus. If pledges are not collected on time, the campus pays. The item doesn't say how much of the $44.8M is already pledged, collected or under signed agreements.
  3. An outside party controls construction. An independent nonprofit (CIII) would run the CMAR contract for a UC-owned building in which UC has about $182M at stake. The Work Agreement is not finished. Allocation of overruns, change-order authority, audit rights and UC oversight are not described.
  4. Counterparty dependence. CIII provides 44.5% of funding. If CIII's funding is delayed, reduced or redirected, or its program changes, UCLA could be left funding the gap or holding unleased lab-ready space.
  5. Retrofit cost risk with no benchmarks. The item says "adequate comparable projects are not available." Building cost is $472/gsf and total P-W-C cost is $609/gsf. Contingency is $28.5M (8.8%), which is thin for a deep retrofit of an existing building with floodplain issues, a rooftop-to-plant conversion and full MEP replacement.
  6. This is only the first installment. The core and shell does not create usable labs. UCLA tenant improvements, the remaining eastern portion and all of Research Park West are later phases "as additional tenants are identified and funding is secured." Our total commitment to make this facility productive is not shown.
  7. No revenue case is shown. The item gives no lease income from CIII, sublease or industry revenue, indirect cost recovery or operating cost projections. Repayment relies entirely on campus general revenues.
  8. Research funding environment. The campus already fails coverage tests. Its general revenues depend partly on federal research funding, which has been volatile, and the item does not discuss this sensitivity.
  9. Reimbursement and timing. The financing may reimburse prior spending, and the revised sources table shows external financing and gift funds in phases previously approved as campus and CIII funds. Advanced Work construction began in October, before this financing approval.

Questions I would want answered

Debt affordability

  1. What specific conditions led the CFO to grant the Debt Policy exception, and what is the campus plan and timeline for getting back to ≥0.0% margin and ≥1.1x coverage?
  2. The benchmark table lists the minimum metrics in "2025." Which projection year is the low point, and what do the ten-year margin and coverage trajectories look like year by year?
  3. What other UCLA campus financings are planned in the same ten-year window, and are they in the Debt Affordability Model that produced these numbers?
  4. What are coverage and cash-on-hand under a downside scenario: a 10–20% drop in federal research funding, lower state support, or rates of 5.5–6%?
  5. If the exception is granted, what reporting will the Regents receive, and are there triggers that would pause future UCLA borrowing?

Gift funding

  1. How much of the $44.82M is in signed pledges, how much is received, and how much is still prospective? What is the pledge payment schedule against the $2.67M annual debt service?
  2. If gifts fall short, does the shortfall fall entirely on campus general revenues? Has that downside been modeled in the coverage ratio?

CIII relationship and delivery

  1. What is the source of CIII's $145.9M? Is it fully committed and on hand, or subject to appropriation, fundraising or milestones?
  2. Under the draft Work Agreement, who bears cost overruns on the core and shell? Is the "pro-rata share" fixed, or does UCLA absorb increases?
  3. What approval rights, audit rights and change-order controls will UC have over a CIII-managed CMAR contract? Who holds the guaranteed maximum price?
  4. Why should the Regents approve the full budget and financing before the Work Agreement is executed? Should approval be conditioned on execution of an agreement meeting specified terms?
  5. Using one CMAR for both UC core and shell and CIII tenant improvements is said to save time and money. How will costs be kept separate so UC does not subsidize CIII's tenant work?
  6. What happens to UCLA's investment if CIII defaults on its lease or affiliation obligations, or dissolves?

Scope, cost and economics

  1. Without comparables, what independent cost estimate or peer review validated the $327.9M budget? Is 8.8% contingency adequate for a building of this age and condition, including flood mitigation?
  2. What is the estimated total cost, including UCLA tenant improvements, to make UCLA's share of Research Park East fully operational, and how will it be funded?
  3. What rent will CIII and other tenants pay, and what are projected operating and maintenance costs? Does the project produce net income for the campus or a net cost?
  4. How much of the 530,000 gsf is committed to identified tenants, and how much is speculative?
  5. What is the remaining flood risk after mitigation, and what are the insurance implications for lab space in a floodplain?

Item F7: UCLA West Valley Medical Center Replacement Hospital and Parking Structure (Preliminary Plans Funding)

What is being proposed

  • Build a replacement acute care hospital of about 585,000 gsf on the East Campus of the former West Hills Hospital, acquired in March 2024. The existing 188,000-gsf hospital was built in 1973, does not meet SB 1953 seismic standards, and UCLA Health now says a retrofit is not financially or operationally feasible.
  • Tentative program: 260–300 licensed beds, an emergency department, interventional services, advanced radiology, a burn unit, clinical support and an all-electric central utility plant. Also included: a 650-space parking structure built first, demolition of old buildings, and limited improvements to the existing ED/ICU building, whose new use is undefined.
  • Request: $120 million for preliminary plans, from hospital reserves. Of that, $87.5M (72.9%) is architecture and engineering fees and $25.7M (21.4%) is special items.
  • The total project budget is not disclosed. UCLA Health will return in spring 2028 (parking structure) and fall 2028 (hospital) for full budgets, external financing and design approval. Environmental review under CEQA has not yet been done.
  • Schedule: about nine years. Hospital completion is expected in 2034 and the full project in 2036. UCLA Health told the state agency (HCAI) the project will not meet the 2030 seismic deadline.
  • Hospital system financials (as of June 30, 2025): 15.5% modified net margin, 8.7x modified debt service coverage, 219 days cash. Ten-year projections meet Debt Policy.

Key risk flags

  1. Very large commitment with no total cost. $120M of preliminary planning is a large sum on its own. It strongly implies a total project well above $1 billion, but no estimate is given. Once $120M is spent, pressure to approve the full project in 2028 will be considerable.
  2. Acquisition due-diligence questions. When UCLA bought the hospital, it expected to renovate and retrofit it into compliance. Two and a half years later, that plan is deemed infeasible and a full replacement is proposed. The Regents should understand what changed and whether the purchase price and business case anticipated this.
  3. Seismic and regulatory exposure. The project will miss the 2030 SB 1953 deadline by about four years. The item says HCAI will stop approving any modifications to the existing facility without an acceptable plan. It does not say what penalties, licensing actions or operating restrictions could follow if HCAI does not grant an extension. Patients would also stay in a non-compliant 1973 building through 2034.
  4. Limited capacity gain. Beds go from 260 licensed to 260–300, while building area roughly triples (188,000 to 585,000 gsf). The growth case depends more on new service lines (burn unit, interventional, tertiary care) than on beds.
  5. Financial data are dated and the outlook is uncertain. Hospital metrics are as of June 30, 2025, more than 16 months old. Hospital finances face potential pressure from federal Medicaid changes, payer mix shifts, labor costs and construction cost inflation. The projected coverage range of 3.4x–9.8x is wide.
  6. Reserves are being drawn for multiple purposes. UCLA Health has major capital needs and recent acquisitions. The item doesn't show the cumulative draw on reserves or how this project ranks against other commitments.
  7. Scope is still undefined. The bed count, square footage, ED/ICU reuse and service mix will be "refined." The PDB method sets a guaranteed maximum price only after award and design. That brings early contractor input but less early cost certainty.
  8. Operational and site risks. The existing hospital must keep operating during roughly nine years of construction. The new parking structure (650 spaces) replaces part of today's 1,070 surface spaces. An all-electric central plant for an acute care hospital raises questions about resilience and backup power.

Questions I would want answered

Total cost and financing

  1. What is UCLA Health's current estimated range for total project cost, including the parking structure, demolition and ED/ICU work? What will the financing mix be (debt versus reserves versus philanthropy)?
  2. Why is $120M (with $87.5M in A&E fees) the right size for preliminary plans? What share of total cost does it represent, and how does it compare with other recent UC hospital replacement projects?
  3. If the full project is later scaled back, delayed or rejected, how much of the $120M would still be useful (for example for a retrofit or a smaller alternative)?
  4. Can the $120M be released in tranches tied to milestones, such as a cost estimate after programming, before all of it is committed?

Acquisition history and alternatives

  1. What was the purchase price for the East and West Campus properties? What retrofit cost was assumed at acquisition, and what did the later assessment find?
  2. What alternatives were evaluated: a phased retrofit, a smaller replacement, building on the West Campus parcels, or partnering with another provider? Please provide the comparative costs.
  3. What lessons from this acquisition apply to future UC health system acquisitions and their due diligence?

Seismic compliance and regulation

  1. Has HCAI formally accepted the plan or granted an extension beyond 2030? If not, what are the possible consequences, including fines, license restrictions or forced closure of inpatient services?
  2. What interim measures will protect patients and staff in the 1973 building until 2034?
  3. Which schedule milestones are critical to keep HCAI's cooperation, and what happens if the 2028 approvals slip?

Business case and finances

  1. Please provide updated hospital system financials for FY 2025-26 and a downside scenario reflecting federal Medicaid and payer changes.
  2. What volume, market share and payer-mix assumptions support a 585,000-gsf facility? What is the expected return on investment?
  3. What are all of UCLA Health's capital commitments over the next ten years, and how much reserve capacity remains after this project?
  4. What drives the new burn unit and tertiary services: demonstrated regional demand, or strategic positioning? What would they cost to staff?

Delivery and operations

  1. How will cost overruns be controlled before a guaranteed maximum price is set under PDB? What cost reports will the Regents receive?
  2. Is 650 structured spaces enough once the new hospital and repurposed ED/ICU are fully operating? Will additional parking or traffic mitigation be needed?
  3. How will an all-electric central plant meet hospital requirements for continuous operation during grid outages or a major earthquake?
  4. What is the plan and budget for the repurposed ED/ICU building, and could it add material cost later?

Cross-cutting concern

Both items fall on UCLA's balance sheet at the same meeting. They show a sharp contrast: the health system reports strong margins and coverage, while the campus side fails the Debt Policy. I would ask the CFO for a combined view of UCLA's ten-year borrowing and reserve use across campus and health. I would also ask whether a series of Debt Policy exceptions for the campus is becoming the norm rather than the exception.

Possible conditions to consider (F6)

  • Make the financing approval effective only after a CIII Work Agreement is executed with UC cost-overrun protection, audit rights and approval rights over changes.
  • Require documentation of committed CIII funds and gift pledges before drawing on the gift-supported financing.
  • Require an annual report to the Committee on campus debt metrics until they return to compliance.

Arithmetic note: funding sources total $327.864M, and the stated debt service figures check out at 4.25% over 30 years. The over-$1-billion figure for F7 is my own rough inference from the size of the planning budget and the building; it is not a number in the agenda item. 

Straws in the Wind - Part 529

From Inside Higher Ed: Article reviews generated by artificial intelligence are “now better” than the best humans can produce by every measure, two Harvard professors have admitted, despite it throwing into doubt the future of their own peer-review service.

Gary King, director of the Institute for Quantitative Social Science at Harvard University, and Steven Worthington, director of data science at IQSS, investigated reviews of papers submitted to rapidPeer, their double-blind peer-review service for university faculty members... But that is “not what we found,” and subsequently, King said, “we’re going to have to pivot what the organization does.” ... 

Full story at https://www.insidehighered.com/index%2ephp/news/faculty/books-publishing/2026/11/05/ai-article-review-better-humans-their-best.

Attend?


Back in the day when he was Lieutenant Governor Newsom, and not yet Governor Newsom, he would attend UC Regents meetings, as shown above. (Lieutenant governors are ex officio Regents, and they don't have a lot else to do.) As governor, however, the only time Newsom showed up was in a closed-door meeting when he berated UCLA for switching athletic conferences. So today's the last time as governor, he could appear in an open session at the Regents. 

Probably, he won't, however. He has another decision to make:


Or direct to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AhUnj38RlfY. 

Can Newsom Decide? Lyrics: Dan Mitchell © Nov. 15, 2026 Music and singing: Suno Is Newsom running for the prez? I keep listening to what he says. For Kamala he said he's waiting Leaving my heart just palpitating. He acts like he’s a candidate Going so often out of state Leaving everyone to debate, Who’d be the VP on his slate. Can I depend on Governor Newsom? Would the result for Dems be gruesome? Now he tells me, let January come, Uncertainty seems his rule of thumb. ‘Cause when the governor’s a lame duck, He may think he can just pass the buck. And leave me guessing like a schmuck. Left to worry about my luck. Now he seems to be having a blast, Appearing on a controversial podcast. He seems not worried, his time is past. But can he make the tension last? Ultimately, any politician Can become an apparition His campaign, an abolition If he can’t make a decision. So, Governor Newsom, it’s now time, For your decision-tree to climb. Lift your campaign up from the grime. The midnight deadline’s soon to chime. If you don’t run, there’s always PlumpJack, If you think they’ll want you back. Running a winery’s a fine hack. But it’s way off the political track. Thing is, keeping us in suspense, And just sitting on the fence, Could make the electorate think you’re dense. You could end up nowhere like Mike Pence. So, governor, get off the can. Make a decision; don’t be an almost-ran. If you want me to be your fan. Let me know. Just be a man.

Parallel Blogs / Subscribing / New Song

We have been putting out this blog since 2009 under the heading "UCLA Faculty Association" using the link:

https://uclafacultyassociation.blogspot.com/

The blog site was originally created by the then-executive director of the Faculty Association. As such, yours truly does not have control of the site; he is simply a blogger on it. So when technical issues arise, that can be a problem. Given that issue, we have been adding a parallel site with the same blog entries since July 23rd:

https://danmitchellsblogcontinues.blogspot.com/

We will be running the two in parallel for the indefinite future. Possibly, at some point we will switch to the new link.

If you read the blog using the Facebook page of Yousee Elayemeriti, you can continue to do so:

https://www.facebook.com/yousee.elayemeriti

===

Want to subscribe?

You can't subscribe directly. But you can subscribe indirectly to this blog via a service called Blogtrottr. Go to blogtrottr.com and fill in the URL for the blog:

https://danmitchellsblogcontinues.blogspot.com/ 

or

https://uclafacultyassociation.blogspot.com/

and put in your email address. 

You will then receive an email at the email address you provided asking you to confirm. After you confirm, you will receive an email notification of new postings whenever they appear. If there are, say, three postings on a particular day, you will receive three notifications (one for each one). 

Note and full disclosure: There are ads on these notifications. 

==

And here's a little song, based on the information above, lyrics by Dan Mitchell, music by Suno:


Or direct to https://ia601408.us.archive.org/5/items/sharp-and-clever-pen/Parallel%20Jingle%20%282%20versions%29.mp4.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

More Regental Questions


Just as I asked Claude yesterday to go over some health-related matters at the Regents and come up with questions the Regents could be/should be asking, I did the same for item c2 - on today's agenda - which involves approval of "military" weapons for the UCPD. Blog readers will recall that we summarized the UCLA public Zoom on this issue a few days ago. So I asked for UCLA-specific issues. Below is the response: 

Regent's Briefing Memo: AB 481 Military Equipment Report and Policy

Item: C2, Compliance and Audit Committee, meeting of November 17, 2026 (Action Item – Consent)  NOTE: CLAUDE GOT THE IDEA THAT THIS IS A CONSENT ITEM, MAYBE FROM THE LETTER C. IT DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE A CONSENT ITEM.
Documents reviewed: C2 item memo (5 pp.); Attachment 1, model "Military Equipment" policy (5 pp.); Attachment 2, Annual Report by the UC Council of Chiefs of Police (11 pp.); notes on the Nov. 4, 2026 UCLA PD AB 481 community Zoom (Dan Mitchell's blog, Nov. 9, 2026).
Perspective: Written as if by a Regent preparing for the meeting.

1. What we are being asked to do

The President recommends that the committee advise the full Board to approve (a) the systemwide military equipment use policy (Attachment 1) and (b) the 2026 annual report, including the new equipment requested (Attachment 2). AB 481 (2021) requires that every year we vote in an open meeting to renew the policy. To do so we must determine that: the equipment is necessary because no reasonable alternative exists; the policy safeguards welfare, safety, civil rights and civil liberties; purchases are reasonably cost-effective; and past uses complied with policy, or corrective action was taken.

The item is on the consent agenda, so unless a Regent pulls it, it will be approved without discussion. NOTE AGAIN THAT CLAUDE IS INCORRECT THAT THIS IS A CONSENT ITEM. IT IS NOT SO LISTED. WHETHER THE REGENTS WILL HAVE A DISCUSSION IS UP TO THEM.

2. Summary of the documents

C2 memo. It describes the covered equipment as "less lethal alternatives to standard-issue firearms for use in extraordinary public circumstances". It says the equipment is not surplus or "military grade". It also says no campus takes part in the federal 1033 (LESO) surplus program. Categories listed: a Berkeley bomb robot, breaching rounds, distraction devices ("flash-bangs"), LRAD acoustic devices, and less-lethal launchers, impact munitions and chemical agents. It cites training through POST and others, as well as the Robinson-Edley Report, the Presidential Task Force on Universitywide Policing and the UC Community Safety Plan.

Attachment 1 (policy). This is a generic Lexipol template. It still has "[campus]" placeholders and a "2022/MM/DD" copyright date. It lists the statutory categories of military equipment and assigns an equipment coordinator. It requires an annual audit, the annual report and a community meeting. Section 1.5(h) lets a department buy, borrow or accept funds for equipment without further approval as long as it stays within the "quantities last approved". Section 1.6 lets a department use other agencies' military equipment, and it adopts their policies when giving mutual aid. The policy contains no rules on when or how any item may be used. Those rules are in separate use-of-force and control-device policies that are not before us.

Attachment 2 (annual report). Highlights:

  • Use: Only two non-training deployments are reported systemwide. UC Davis flew its drone 28 times. UC Riverside's FN 303 launcher was "deployed and available" during mutual aid at Berkeley in November 2025, but it was not fired.
  • Complaints: "No complaints or concerns" at any campus.
  • Audits: No policy violations found anywhere.
  • Costs (FY 2025-26, purchases and maintenance only): They range from $1,320 (UCR) to $51,247 (UCB). UCLA reports $25,131 for 120 40mm rounds plus three Skydio X10 drones with docks. UCSD has a drone contract with a first payment of $99,300 due in FY 2026-27. No funding sources are given.
  • Inventory: In addition to less-lethal tools, the inventory includes several hundred AR-15/M4-pattern patrol rifles across the system and roughly 400,000+ rounds of rifle ammunition. For example, UCSF has 93,000 rounds and UCSD has 50 Ruger AR rifles. Each campus has one or two LRADs.
  • New requests: UCLA (see below). UCR wants 2 drones and UCSB wants 12 more patrol rifles for administrative vehicles. UCSD wants 11,000 rifle rounds and UC Merced wants 200 40mm training kits. UCOP has already received $2.05 million in federal funds for four mobile command vehicles for LA28 Olympic Athletes Village security, which will then stay with UCPD systemwide.

3. UCLA specifics

Current UCLA inventory: 3 Skydio X10 drones; 22 Colt patrol rifles and about 42,000 rifle rounds; 18 40mm launchers and 242 40mm eXact Impact rounds; 1 FN 303 and 6 pepper-ball launchers (4 FTC, 2 PepperBall VK-SBL); about 2,875 PAVA pepper-ball projectiles; and 2 LRADs.

UCLA requests:

  • Increase authorized drones from 3 to 5. The stated reasons are that five would cover 95%+ of priority calls, that a "drone as first responder" program needs more than one drone because of battery life, and support for LA28 Athletes Village security. Plus up to 4 training drones at no more than $1,000 each.
  • Raise authorized PAVA pepper-ball projectiles from 3,000 to 4,000 (VXR type from 1,000 to 2,000).
  • New authorizations for inert pepper balls: 750 round and 200 VXR, for "enclosed spaces or sensitive locations".
  • Raise authorized 40mm impact rounds from 300 to 350, to supply launchers "previously approved but not yet purchased".
  • Stated rationale for all of it: growth in UCLA housing, medical and administrative properties, and LA28.

Note that the requests are written as increases in authorized ceilings. Compared with what UCLA has now, the new ceilings would allow about 108 more 40mm rounds (242 to 350) and about 1,125 more PAVA projectiles (2,875 to 4,000). Those are roughly the "~100 rounds" and "~1,000 pepper balls" figures mentioned at the Zoom.

What came out at the Nov. 4 UCLA Zoom:

  • A faculty and staff petition with 400+ signatures asks for an immediate ban on buying and deploying 40mm weapons.
  • Speakers cited a UCLA student hit in the chest by UCLA PD on June 10, 2024 and hospitalized for two days. They also cited a student whose skull was fractured by LAPD in June 2025.
  • A federal injunction limits LAPD's crowd-control use of these weapons and bars aiming at the head or chest. Speakers argued UCLA PD operates under looser standards.
  • Attendees said officers carried launchers at a Bruin Plaza movie screening (April 30, 2025) and at the Chancellor's inauguration (June 5, 2025).
  • A prior Regents report reportedly described about 240 pepper balls fired at an "aggressive crowd" on June 10, 2024. The department said that was not crowd control, and participants disputed that.
  • Officials said two more drones would cost about $216,000. They said most costs come from existing department funds and that the drones are not for general surveillance.
  • Questions about cooperation with ICE were ruled out of scope.

4. Questions I would raise as a Regent

A. Process and the consent agenda

  1. Given a 400+ signature petition at UCLA and public dispute over past uses, should this item be pulled from consent and taken up for discussion and a separate vote? AGAIN NOTE THAT THIS IS NOT LISTED AS A CONSENT ITEM. Should the UCLA requests be voted on separately from the routine renewal?
  2. Most campuses' AB 481 community meetings are due in December, after our vote. How will we hear what the public says before we approve new acquisitions? Where we already have the input, as with UCLA's Nov. 4 meeting, why isn't a summary included in our materials?
  3. Attachment 1 is an unfilled template with "[campus]" placeholders, a stray reference to section "905.6", and no use rules. Are we approving ten campus policies or one generic one? Does a document with no authorized-use rules satisfy AB 481's definition of a "military equipment use policy"? Shouldn't the actual use-of-force and control-device policies be in front of us?
  4. The statute requires an annual report for the preceding calendar year, but the costs shown are for FY 2025-26. Which period does the report cover?

B. Accuracy and completeness of the report

  1. The report says no campus received any "complaints or concerns". How does that fit with the UCLA faculty petition, the concerns voiced at UCLA's 2025 and 2026 AB 481 meetings, and the emails the department invites at info@ucpd.ucla.edu? What does each campus count as a "concern"?
  2. UCR's FN 303 counts as "deployed" because it was carried during mutual aid, even though it was not fired. By that standard, why doesn't UCLA report its launchers carried at the April 30, 2025 Bruin Plaza screening and the June 5, 2025 inauguration? Will the Chiefs adopt a single systemwide definition of "use" and "deployment"?
  3. How were the June 10, 2024 UCLA pepper-ball and 40mm uses reported last year, and was there a finding that they complied with policy? If a student was hospitalized after a 40mm round, what review happened and what corrective action, if any, was taken? AB 481 requires us to make that compliance finding.
  4. Who performed the "internal audits" that found no violations? Were they independent of the departments being audited? Can we see what they examined?
  5. The memo calls this equipment "less lethal alternatives" and "not military grade". Yet the largest category in the inventory is AR-15/M4-pattern rifles and hundreds of thousands of rifle rounds. Shouldn't the Board get an accurate description of what it is approving?
  6. The report shows quantities possessed but not quantities authorized. Section 1.5(h) lets departments buy up to the authorized level without returning to us. Can we get a table of authorized versus possessed for every item and campus? For example, how many 40mm launchers is UCLA authorized but hasn't bought?

C. Costs and funding

  1. AB 481 requires the total annual cost of each type of equipment, including training, transportation, maintenance, storage and upgrades, plus the source of funds for the next year. The report gives only purchases and lists no funding sources. When will a compliant cost report be provided?
  2. UCLA reports $25,131 for three drones with docks plus 120 munitions. At the Zoom, officials put two more drones at about $216,000, and UCSD's two-drone contract starts at $99,300. Is the UCLA figure an installment, a lease, or grant-funded? What is the full multi-year cost of UCLA's drone program, including software subscriptions, docks, pilots and data storage?
  3. What alternatives analysis supports the statutory finding that each new purchase is "reasonably cost-effective"? None appears in the materials.
  4. At a time when UCLA is cutting lecturers and child care, what is the opportunity cost of these purchases, and which budget pays for them?

D. UCLA's 40mm and pepper-ball requests

  1. UCLA PD says these tools are only for people who are assaultive or life-threatening, never for crowd control. Then why are they carried at peaceful events such as a movie screening and an inauguration? What is the written policy on carrying launchers at demonstrations and campus events? Who approves it, and is that decision documented?
  2. A federal injunction now limits LAPD's use of 40mm and similar weapons and bars aiming at the head and chest. Will UC adopt standards at least as protective systemwide? If not, why should a university police force operate under looser rules than the city's police department?
  3. Section 1.6 lets UCPD use other agencies' equipment, and it lets mutual-aid agencies use their own policies on our campuses. When LAPD or another agency responds at UCLA, whose rules apply? Does the injunction follow LAPD onto campus? How will UC prevent "policy shopping" through mutual aid?
  4. How many 40mm and pepper-ball rounds did UCLA use, both in training and operationally, in each of the last three years? Is the request driven by expiration, by new launchers, or by expected events? What are the expiration dates of the current 242 rounds and 2,875 projectiles?
  5. Which specific new UCLA housing, medical and administrative properties justify the increase? How does growth in properties translate into a need for more impact rounds and chemical munitions specifically?
  6. What is the plan for using inert pepper balls "in enclosed spaces or sensitive locations"? Does that include residence halls, hospitals or classrooms, and who authorizes it?
  7. How does the University respond to the faculty petition? Will the Chancellor or UCLA PD give the Board a written response?

E. UCLA drones and the LA28 Olympics

  1. What are the written rules for UCLA's "drone as first responder" program? Specifically: can drones fly over protests, residence halls or medical facilities? Will they record video, use thermal imaging or zoom, or identify faces or license plates? How long is footage kept, and who can see it?
  2. Will drone data or footage be shared with federal agencies, including ICE or DHS, under LA28 security arrangements or otherwise? AB 481 covers collaboration with other agencies, so why were ICE questions ruled out of scope at the UCLA meeting?
  3. Who pays for the LA28-related drones and command vehicles: UC, LA28, or federal grants? What conditions come with that money? After the Games, what limits will keep this equipment from mission creep in routine campus policing?
  4. Three drones were bought but reportedly not yet installed. Why expand to five before the program has any operating record we can review? Should approval for the additional two wait until a year of use data is reported?

F. Systemwide items

  1. UCOP says it "has received" $2.05 million in federal funding for four mobile command vehicles. The policy (Sec. 1.5(b)) and AB 481 require Board approval before seeking or accepting funds for military equipment. When was this money applied for and accepted? Was prior approval obtained? If not, what corrective action is being taken?
  2. Which federal agency provided the $2.05 million, and what strings come with it, such as data-sharing or federal operational control during the Games? Where will the vehicles be based afterward?
  3. UCSB wants 12 more rifles for administrative vehicles, after already putting rifles in all 12 patrol cars. UCSD holds 50 Ruger AR rifles. What principle governs how many rifles a campus police force needs, and how does it compare with comparable universities?
  4. The UCSD ammunition request describes the round as for the "MCX short barrel rifle", but UCSD's inventory lists no MCX rifles; UCI is the campus with MCX rifles. Is this a copy-and-paste error, and what other errors might the report contain?
  5. Will the Board require a single systemwide standard for the use of kinetic and chemical munitions at protests? It could be consistent with Penal Code § 13652 (AB 48), the Robinson-Edley Report and the LAPD injunction, and include mandatory body-camera activation and public reporting of every discharge.

5. Possible motions a Regent might offer

  • Pull C2 from consent and separate the routine renewal from the new-equipment requests. AGAIN, IT IS NOT LISTED AS A CONSENT ITEM.
  • Defer UCLA's 40mm, pepper-ball and drone increases until a full cost report, an authorized-versus-possessed table, written drone and data-sharing rules, and a written response to the faculty petition are provided.
  • Direct UCOP to report back on the timing of approval for the $2.05 million command-vehicle funding.
  • Direct the Council of Chiefs to adopt uniform definitions of "deployment" and "complaint" for next year's report.

Sources: UC Regents Compliance and Audit Committee item C2 and Attachments 1–2 (Nov. 17, 2026 meeting); "UCLA PD Zoom," Dan Mitchell's Blog, Nov. 9, 2026, https://danmitchellsblogcontinues.blogspot.com/2026/11/ucla-pd-zoom.html. Statements attributed to Zoom participants are as reported there and were not independently verified.

Straws in the Wind - Part 528

From Inside Higher Ed: Higher education advocacy groups and institutions excoriated a proposed rule that threatens private, nonprofit institutions’ tax-exempt status. If enacted, the Treasury Department and Internal Revenue Service proposal would allow officials to revoke that exemption if they determine a private college or university has discriminated based on race or ethnicity. But colleges argued in public comments on the plan that it’s unclear and unlawful, and they criticized the agency’s sweeping language in explaining the rule’s intent. The IRS said its regulation would mean “all forms of racial discrimination in education, regardless of the intent behind or the legality of such discrimination (for example, where such discrimination is defended as serving remedial or diversity-related objectives), are against a fundamental public policy of the United States and thus preclude a school’s exemption from Federal income tax.”

Losing the federal income tax exemption could make donors hesitate to give to universities because they wouldn’t be able to write contributions off on their taxes...

Full story at https://www.insidehighered.com/news/institutions/private-nonprofit-colleges/2026/11/04/proposal-could-ax-college-tax-exemptions.

Closing


From the Daily Bruin's notes on the North Westwood Neighborhood Council:

...Alexandra Dildine, a field representative for California State Assembly member Rick Chavez Zbur, said Zbur was reelected to represent Westwood in the California State Assembly. She added that Zbur’s office and state Sen. Ben Allen’s office sent a letter to Chancellor Julio Frenk, calling on UCLA to reconsider the closure of its childcare centers – though they have not yet received a response from the university...


Seems like a little music is needed: