The Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) has issued its November budget outlook publication:
Stock Market Poses a Serious Risk to Revenues. Since 2023, the state budget has been the beneficiary of an extended stock market boom. Even now this boom appears to be resulting in continued strength in income tax collections. That said, while the stock market’s recent run has been great for many investors and the state budget, it now appears to have advanced to a dangerous stage. The risk now facing state revenues is that this boom, like many in the past, will abruptly end in a bust.
This Fiscal Outlook Meaningfully Incorporates This Risk. The state must decide how much revenue it can depend on having to pay for current services to Californians who rely on them. We view building a state budget around revenues that do not incorporate the meaningful danger of a market downturn as unduly risky. As such, our Fiscal Outlook explicitly incorporates this risk in two ways. First, to offer some insurance against a stock market downturn, our revenue forecast is somewhat weaker than suggested by recent collection trends, but still well above where it would be if a market crash occurred. This is the forecast we recommend policymakers use as a starting point to reduce the likelihood the state makes commitments it will be unable to afford in the future. Second, to gauge the state’s preparedness for a stock market downturn, we present an estimate of the state’s budget condition under a scenario where the stock market peaks at the end of this year and crashes over the course of 2027.
Under Our Forecast, Existing Commitments Exceed Revenues. Under our forecast, there is a small deficit of $2 billion at the end of 2027‑28. Starting in 2028‑29, however, deficits would be considerably larger, as shown on the left side of the figure. Although these out‑year deficits have narrowed from the ones we projected a year ago—mainly due to the artificial intelligence (AI)‑driven stock market surge and ongoing reductions enacted in this year’s budget—deficits persist because the underlying imbalance has not been fully resolved.
Reserves Not Nearly Sufficient to Cover Shortfalls in the Event of a Stock Market Crash. If the current AI boom is a speculative bubble that ends in a bust, there will be severe budget shortfalls...
Full publication at https://lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/5214.
===
The LAO report provides a table showing the current budget as projected and a "workload" budget - what happens if nothing changes - for next fiscal year which incoming Governor Becerra will present in January. It is shown below:
Of course, Becerra is unlikely to present a workload budget; he will have items he wants to enhance plus those he wants to cut. And his underlying economic projections may vary from those of the LAO. It's also worth noting that as we calculate the deficits in the two years, we get different numbers from the LAO since we avoid budget-speak which confuses stocks and flows. LAO also leaves out other reserve funds associated with the General Fund, the state's basic checking account for day-to-day spending and receipts. But there is a deficit of around $9 billion this year and around $10 billion next year.
We are running deficits in boom times (at least booming from the stock market viewpoint which pours capital gains into the California treasury). So, the notion that a stock market bust would lead to rapid reserve depletion should be evident.