What BARD said about Stanford Law's Incident

Earlier today, we posted about the free speech issue that arose at Stanford Law School.* 

From "Bard," the artificial intelligence program of Google:

Question: Given the concerns raised by the student protests against a talk by Judge Duncan at Stanford Law School, what policies should the school implement in case of future incidents?

====

Draft 1:

Here are some policies that Stanford Law School could implement in case of future incidents:

A clear and concise policy on free speech. The policy should state that students have the right to express their opinions, even if those opinions are unpopular or controversial. The policy should also state that students are not allowed to disrupt or prevent others from speaking.

A commitment to transparency and accountability. The school should make sure that all students are aware of the free speech policy and that they know how to report violations of the policy. The school should also investigate any reports of violations and take appropriate action.

A commitment to diversity and inclusion. The school should make sure that all students feel welcome and respected, regardless of their background or beliefs. The school should also provide training on diversity and inclusion to all students and staff.

====

Draft 2:

Stanford Law School should implement the following policies in case of future incidents of student protests:

The school should reaffirm its commitment to free speech and academic freedom. This means that students should be able to express their opinions, even if they are unpopular, and that speakers should be able to express their views without fear of being silenced.

The school should develop a clear policy on protests and disruptions. This policy should make it clear that protests are allowed, but that they must be peaceful and respectful. Disruptive behavior, such as shouting down speakers or blocking access to buildings, should not be tolerated.

The school should provide training to students on how to engage in peaceful protests. This training should cover topics such as how to express your views effectively, how to deal with disagreements, and how to de-escalate tense situations.

The school should have a process in place for resolving disputes between students and speakers. This process should be fair and impartial, and it should allow both students and speakers to have their voices heard.

The school should work to create a more inclusive and welcoming environment for all students. This means addressing issues of racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination on campus.

By taking these steps, Stanford Law School can create a campus environment where students can express their views freely and where all students feel welcome and respected.

====

Draft 3:

Stanford Law School should implement the following policies in case of future incidents:

Enforce its speech policy. The school's speech policy prohibits shutting down speakers through heckling. The school should make clear to students that this policy will be enforced, and that students who disrupt speakers will be subject to disciplinary action.

Provide training on free speech. The school should provide training to students on the importance of free speech and the proper way to express disagreement with speakers. This training should include examples of how to engage in respectful and constructive dialogue with speakers.

Create a forum for students to express their concerns. The school should create a forum for students to express their concerns about speakers and other issues. This forum should be a safe and respectful space where students can share their views and have their voices heard.

Be transparent about its decision-making process. The school should be transparent about its decision-making process for inviting speakers and for responding to protests. The school should make clear to students how it will make decisions about these matters, and should be open to feedback from students.

These policies will help to ensure that Stanford Law School is a place where students can express their views freely and where respectful dialogue can take place.

====

*https://uclafacultyassociation.blogspot.com/2023/03/stanford-law-tries-to-turn-it-around.html.