Sunday, September 29, 2019

Telescope Continues - Continued

An odd twist. According to a local Hawaiian newspaper, although the state's supreme court provided an OK to the TMT project, a state agency has been providing financial support to the protesters who are blocking the project:*

OHA reveals protest support, subpoena response

Honolulu Star-Advertiser, 9-27-19, via UCOP News Notes of 9-27-19, Timothy Hurley,

The Office of Hawaiian Affairs has spent more than $39,000 in support of the protest against the construction of the Thirty Meter Telescope on Mauna Kea.

The OHA board of trustees released its expenditures to the public Thursday and also said it provided some but not all of the Mauna Kea support-related documents demanded by a subpoena from the state Attorney General’s Office.

“While OHA has provided the Attorney General certain documents responsive to its subpoena, we are reviewing each category of items requested for production by the AG on a case by case basis,” the agency said in a statement Thursday.

The trustees reviewed OHA’s Mauna Kea expenditures in front of a full house at its Iwilei headquarters during a meeting in which scores of beneficiaries thanked the board for its Mauna Kea support and appealed for more aid.

The OHA trustees approved a resolution July 25 that authorized the agency’s administration to advocate for the rights, safety and well-being of Native Hawaiian “protectors” and provide related assistance.

As of Sept. 17, OHA spent $39,052 and committed 159 staff hours on digital media services while fulfilling the mandate of a resolution, according to a report by interim OHA CEO Sylvia Hussey.

Three-fourths of the money went to the Puu Huluhulu protest camp at the base of Mauna Kea Access Road and paid for toilet rentals and servicing, dumpster removal and landfill disposal fees, and tent rental and lighting.

More than $8,000 went to staff and trustee travel for site visits and beneficiary assessments and for a community meeting, and more than $2,200 underwrote legal observers, including workshop supplies and travel.

Officials were quick to point out that no funds were authorized for the legal defense of those arrested on the mountain, although they did add that less than $1,000 was used to send to the Big Island a handful of attorneys interested in providing pro bono representation.

“We’ve been focusing specifically on the rights of our beneficiaries to exercise their constitutional rights and providing for the public health and safety of our beneficiaries,” said Jocelyn Doane, OHA’s public policy manager. “I think that’s really important because the media is suggesting that we’re paying for their legal defense or paying for their bail fund, that we’re paying for all kinds of things we’re not paying for.”

Chairwoman Colette Machado added, “This is an update that we wanted to give to the public. We don’t have anything to hide.”

The mostly Native Hawaiian protesters have been blocking Mauna Kea Access Road since July 15, preventing construction of the $1.4 billion next-generation project planned as one of the most powerful telescopes in the world.

OHA trustee Carmen Hulu Lindsey was one of dozens of demonstrators who were arrested July 17. Trustee Dan Ahuna was on the mountain the day before, and several of the trustees have visited the camp at other times. The trustees visited the Mauna Kea protest site as a group last week during an annual trip to Hawaii island.

Lindsey volunteered that OHA funds were not used in her case.

“I have my own attorney. I was up on the mountain that day at my own expense. So nothing here other than the travel of the one trip is accountable to me. I just wanted to make that clear,” she said.

Kamehameha Schools also has acknowledged providing help to the protest, including a large tent and support for documentation of the protests through livestreams, photos and videos.

OHA spokesman Sterling Wong said the agency expects to monitor the needs of the encampment and continue to provide a level of support that fulfills the mandate of the board’s resolution as long as necessary.

The OHA trustees took a number of positions in the resolution, including condemning any further provocation or intimidation of those seeking to protect the mountain and discouraging the use of unwarranted force against peaceful protest.

The resolution also called on the governor to rescind his emergency proclamation, which he did, but offered no position on the actual location of the TMT.

During some two hours of testimony Thursday, testifiers praised the board for its financial support and said OHA was helping to give rise to a cultural renaissance.

“Our nation is finally rising,” former Hawaiian-studies teacher Malia Marquez said. “I beg of you to continue to support our lahui (nation). The people of the world are watching.”

Lanakila Mangauil, one of the leaders of the kiai, or “protectors” of the mountain, offered his appreciation.

“Aloha for doing what OHA is supposed to be doing,” he said. “This is what’s galvanizing our people — unlike we’ve ever seen before. Right now, as we speak, in Waimanalo our people are standing. They are being arrested for standing for the right to protect aina. And for too long we’ve all been ignored, and that’s why you’ve got this monstrosity of a city here.

“We are waking up. We are going to continue to stand, and your support is greatly needed. The other side has a lot of support behind them. They have dropped over a half a million dollars in media just a couple of months ago. They got choke support already.”

University of Hawaii graduate student Ilima Long said OHA’s financial support has helped to buttress a new thirst for knowledge among Hawaiians.

She said 651 classes have been held at the Mauna Kea encampment, as part of what’s being called Puu Huluhulu University. The classes, she said, have been taught by 42 college-level professors, 12 lecturers and a variety of others with cultural and special knowledge.

“People are absolutely inspired by what they see up on the mauna,” Long said. “They see that now is a time to really know who we are, to know where we come from, to know our culture, to know our language, and that is what this movement is inspiring, which is absolutely in alignment with the strategic priorities of OHA.”

Teacher Imaikalani Winchester brought a bunch of students from Halau Ku Mana Public Charter School to witness the board meeting.

“It’s time to say aole to bad business,” Winchester told the trustees. “It’s time to say aole to desecration, aole to exploitation. And the division that is being caused by the media throughout our communities have failed. They’ve only made us stronger.”

*Apparently, the OHA support for the protests has been known for some time. See:

And it appears that at earlier in the sequence of events, OHA supported the building of TMT:
Meanwhile, public opinion appears to be split in Hawaii. Your truly has looked at some comments in state newspapers. Here's one:

A reasonable compromise suggested regarding TMT

Sept. 27, 2019, Maui News

The TMT developers have the legal right to build their telescope. Likewise, those opposed to the project have the right to express their objections to TMT on spiritual grounds.

A reasonable compromise can be achieved if both of the parties consider the following suggestions to bring about a win-win result. The developers dedicate the project to honor and recognize the great contributions that the Polynesian people made in utilizing astronomy to navigate the Pacific Ocean and settle in Hawaii. To memorialize this great accomplishment, the observatory be named after the appropriate god chosen by the protesters. Additionally, some land adjacent to TMT be dedicated as “sacred ground” upon which a heiau and other appropriate religious structures can be built to acknowledge the sacred nature of the mountain upon which TKT is built.

Additionally, at the foot of Mauna Kea the State of Hawaii and the TMT consortium build a world-class museum that tells the story of the brave Polynesian seafaring people. Incorporated as part of the museum, a planetarium be built to help people better understand our universe and to show them the role that telescopes, like the TMT, are contributing to help us obtain as much information and knowledge as we can about “What’s out there?”

Finally, the crown for this outstanding and unique museum would be the world famous Hokulea for accomplishing a feat that has gone down in history as just awesome and unbelievable.

William Kinaka


No comments: